| 2011 Portage South Black Squirrels 25-7 (17-3 in AA League play) |
| 2010 Alliance White Physical Therapy 27-7 (21-5 in AA League play) |
| 2009 Akron Lasiks 29-12 (18-9 in AA League play) |
| 2008 Akron Lasiks 28-12-2 (18-5-2 in AA League play) |
| 2007 Randolph Reds, 23-11 (17-9 in AA League play) |
| 2006 Sharon Center Cox Painting, 33-8 (21-6 in AA League play), BB18+ Ohio State Tournament Champions |
| 2005 Sharon Center Cox Painting, 28-10 (20-8 in AA League play) |
| 1994 C & P Sales, 24-11 |
| 1993 C & P Sales, 33-9 |
| 1992 C & P Sales, 29-10 |
| 1991 C & P Sales, 34-7 |
| 1990 Wooster |
| 1989 Wooster, 26-8 (league record only) |
| 1988 Akron Omnicor, 25-9 (league record only) |
| 1987 Mansfield, 24-6 (league record only) |
| 1986 C & P Sales, 19-11 (league record only) |
| 1985 Akron Omnicor, 21-7 (league record only) |
| 1984 Field Falcons, 31-4 (league record only) |
| 1983 Field Falcons, 25-5 (league record only) |
| 1982 Crocker's, 32-12 |
| 1981 Crocker's, 23-7 (league record only) |
| 1980 Forest City, 24-10 (league record only) |
| 1979 Forest City, 30-11 |
| 1978 Akron Insulating |
| 1977 Akron Insulating |
| 1976 Akron Insulating |
| 1975 Eaton Sports Pride |
| 1974 Red Pepper Steak House |
| 1973 Eaton Sports Pride, 38-12 |
| 1972 Red Pepper Steak House, 30-6 (league record only) |
| 1971 Akron Insulating |
| 1970 Wayne Knolls Farm |
| 1969 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1968 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1967 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1966 Airmatic Valve |
| 1965 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1964 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1963 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1962 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1961 Tramonte Black Labels, 69-? |
| 1960 Tramonte Black Labels |
| 1958 Krispy Kremes |
| 1956 Old Dutch Beer |
| 1954 Borden Autos |
| 1953 Canton Road Furniture |
| 1952 St. Marys |
| 1950 Borden Autos |
| 1949 Borden Autos |
| 1948 Borden Autos |
| 1947 Akron Orphans |
| 1946 Smith Sheriffs |
| 1945 Akron Orphans, 53-6-3 overall record, NABF National Champions |
| 1941 Goodrich Local #5 |
| 1940 Goodrich Local #5 |
